Aqueous primary dispersions, method for producing same, and use thereof

10208134 ยท 2019-02-19

    Inventors

    Cpc classification

    International classification

    Abstract

    The invention relates to aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersions comprising dispersed polymer particles having a Z-average particle diameter of 5 to 500 nm and which are obtainable by emulsion polymerization of at least one olefinically unsaturated monomer (A). The emulsion polymerization takes place in the presence of one or more emulsifiers (E) having the following general formula: R.sup.1N(R.sup.2)(R.sup.3), where R.sup.1 is a moiety with 15 to 40 carbon atoms which contains at least one aromatic group and at least one aliphatic group, and which contains at least one functional group selected from hydroxyl groups, thiol groups, and primary or secondary amino groups, and/or has at least one carbon-carbon multiple bond, and R.sup.2 and R.sup.3, independently of one another, are the same or different aliphatic moieties containing 1 to 14 carbon atoms. The invention further relates to a method for producing the primary dispersions, and to coating agents which include the primary dispersions, and to the use of the primary dispersions for producing electrodeposition coatings, and also to conductive substrates coated with the coating compositions.

    Claims

    1. An aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion comprising dispersed polymer particles which: i. have a Z-average particle diameter of 5 to 500 nm, and ii. are obtained by an emulsion polymerization of at least one olefinically unsaturated monomer (A), the emulsion polymerization taking place in the presence of one or more emulsifiers (E) having the following formula:
    R.sup.1N(R.sup.2)(R.sup.3), where R.sup.1 is a moiety with 15 to 40 carbon atoms which contains at least one aromatic group and at least one aliphatic group, and which contains at least one functional group selected from the group consisting of hydroxyl groups, thiol groups, primary amino groups, secondary amino groups, at least one carbon-carbon multiple bond, and mixtures thereof, and R.sup.2 and R.sup.3, independently of one another, are the same or different aliphatic moieties containing 1 to 14 carbon atoms.

    2. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 1, wherein the moiety R.sup.1 has the structure Gr.sub.ali1-Gr.sub.arom-Gr.sub.ali2-, where Gr.sub.arom stands for an aromatic group, Gr.sub.ali1 stands for a first aliphatic group, and Gr.sub.ali2 stands for a second aliphatic group.

    3. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 2, wherein the moiety R.sup.1 in the aliphatic group Gram has at least one carbon-carbon multiple bond.

    4. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 2, wherein the moiety R.sup.1 in the aliphatic group Gr.sub.ali2 has at least one functional group selected from the group consisting of hydroxyl groups, thiol groups, primary amino groups, and secondary amino groups.

    5. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 4, wherein the moiety R.sup.1 in the aliphatic group Gr.sub.ali2 has a functional group selected from the group consisting of hydroxyl groups, thiol groups, primary amino groups, and secondary amino groups in the beta-position with respect to the nitrogen atom in the general formula of the emulsifier according to claim 1.

    6. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 2, wherein: Gr.sub.ali1 is linear, unsubstituted, and free of heteroatoms and has one to three carbon-carbon double bonds, Gr.sub.arom is a phenylene or naphthylene group, and Gr.sub.ali2 is linear, contains a hydroxyl group in the beta-position with respect to the nitrogen atom in the general formula of the emulsifier (E), and additionally contains O in the form of an ether group as a heteroatom.

    7. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 1, wherein at least two of the moieties R.sup.1, R.sup.2, and R.sup.3 bear a functional group selected from the group consisting of hydroxyl groups, thiol groups, primary amino groups, secondary amino groups, and mixtures thereof.

    8. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 7, wherein in addition to containing at least one functional group selected from the group consisting of hydroxyl groups, thiol groups, primary amino groups and secondary amino groups, the moieties R.sup.2 and R.sup.3 bear at least one additional functional group selected from ether groups, ester groups, and amide groups.

    9. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 1, wherein a mixture of emulsifiers (E) is used in which more than 50 mol-% of the moieties R.sup.1 have carbon-carbon multiple bonds.

    10. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 1, wherein the olefinically unsaturated monomer (A) is selected from the group consisting of: a1) (meth)acrylic acid esters which are free of acid groups; a2) monomers which bear at least one hydroxyl group, or one primary, secondary, tertiary, or quaternary amino group, or one alkoxymethylamino group or one imino group per molecule, which are free of acid groups and which are different from the emulsifiers (E); a3) monomers which bear at least one acid group per molecule which may be converted to the corresponding acid anion group; a4) vinyl esters of monocarboxylic acids, branched in the alpha-position, containing 5 to 18 carbon atoms in the molecule; a5) reaction products of acrylic acid and/or methacrylic acid with the glycidyl ester of a monocarboxylic acid branched in the alpha-position and containing 5 to 18 carbon atoms per molecule; a6) cyclic or acyclic olefins; a7) (meth)acrylic acid amides; a8) monomers containing epoxy groups; a9) vinyl aromatic hydrocarbons; a10) acrylonitrile or methacrylonitrile; a11) vinyl compounds selected from the group of vinyl halides, vinylidene dihalides, N-vinyl amides, vinyl ethers, and vinyl esters that are different from the monomers a4); a12) allyl compounds; a13) polysiloxane macromonomers having a number average molecular weight M.sub.n of 1000 to 40,000 and an average of 0.5 to 2.5 ethylenically unsaturated double bonds per molecule; a14) acryloxysilane-containing vinyl monomers; and mixtures thereof.

    11. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 10, wherein the olefinically unsaturated monomer (A) is selected from the group consisting of monomers a1), a2), a9) and the mixtures thereof.

    12. The aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 10, wherein a mixture of olefinically unsaturated monomers (A) is used which comprises: monomers a1) selected from the group of (meth)acrylic acid alkyl esters or (meth)acrylic acid cycloalkyl esters containing up to 20 carbon atoms in the alkyl or cycloalkyl moiety, monomers a2) selected from the group comprising monomers which bear at least one hydroxyl group or a primary, secondary, tertiary, or quaternary amino group, and styrene as monomers a9).

    13. A method for producing an aqueous cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 1 comprising the steps of: (1) introducing into an aqueous medium the olefinically unsaturated monomer(s) (A) and the emulsifier(s) (E) and, optionally, at least one crosslinking agent and/or further binders, (2) then converting the mixture of step (1) into a mini-emulsion using shear forces, and (3) then carrying out an emulsion polymerization reaction on the mini-emulsion.

    14. The method according to claim 13, further comprising addition of one or more crosslinking agents selected from the group consisting of blocked polyisocyanates, tris(alkoxycarbonylamino)triazines, completely etherified aminoplast resins, and mixtures thereof.

    15. The method according to claim 13 further comprising an epoxy amine adduct used as a further binder.

    16. The method according to claim 13, wherein the polymerization is carried out using at least one of a temperature of 25 to 95? C., a pressure of 1.5 to 3000 bar or both.

    17. The method according to claim 13, wherein the emulsion polymerization is initiated by at least one water-soluble initiator selected from the group consisting of sodium persulfate, potassium persulfate, ammonium persulfate, tert-butyl hydroperoxide, and mixtures thereof.

    18. A coating composition comprising an aqueous, cationically stabilized primary dispersion according to claim 1.

    19. The coating composition according to claim 18, wherein it is an electrodeposition coating composition.

    20. The coating composition according to claim 19, wherein the electrodeposition coating composition is cathodically depositable.

    21. An electrically conductive substrate coated with a coating composition according to claim 18.

    22. The coated electrically conductive substrate according to claim 21, wherein it is a metallic substrate.

    23. The electrically conductive substrate according to claim 21, wherein it is an automotive body or a part thereof.

    Description

    EXEMPLARY EMBODIMENTS

    (1) Production of Emulsifier E1 According to the Invention

    (2) 1417.2 parts Cardolite NC 513 (EEW 532 g/eq) were heated to 70? C., with stirring, in a reaction vessel equipped with a stirrer, reflux cooler, temperature probe, nitrogen inlet, and dropping funnel. 282.9 parts diethanolamine were then added dropwise over a period of 15 min. Stirring was continued until all NH equivalents had reacted and an epoxy amine value (a parameter which reflects the combined material quantities of epoxy groups and amino groups) of 1.57 mmol/g was achieved. As soon as the mixture had cooled to 30? C., 300 parts 80% lactic acid were slowly added dropwise and the mixture was stirred for 30 at room temperature.

    (3) Production of Emulsifier E2 According to the Invention

    (4) Production of an Addition Product of Diethylene Triamine and ?-Caprolactone:

    (5) 456.0 parts ?-caprolactone together with 206.0 parts diethylene triamine were placed in a reaction vessel equipped with a stirrer, reflux cooler, temperature probe, and nitrogen inlet and heated to 80? C., with stirring. After 4 hours, an additional 50.0 parts ?-caprolactone were added and stirring was continued for 2 hours before the temperature was increased to 110? C. Stirring was then continued until all primary amine groups had reacted and an MEQ base value of 2.80 mmol/g was achieved, but at least for an additional 3 hours.

    (6) Production of Emulsifier E2:

    (7) 532.0 parts Cardolite NC 513 (EEW 532 g/eq) together with 357.1 parts of the addition product of diethylene triamine and ?-caprolactone produced above were heated to 80? C., with stirring, in a reaction vessel equipped with a stirrer, reflux cooler, temperature probe, and nitrogen inlet, until all NH equivalents had reacted and an epoxy amine value of 1.12 mmol/g was achieved, but at least for two hours. 93.4 parts 90% lactic acid were then added, and stirring was performed for 30 minutes at 80? C.

    (8) Production of a Mini-Emulsion M1 Hybrid Stabilized by an Epoxy Amine Adduct and In Situ Polymerization Thereof:

    (9) Production of an Epoxy Amine Monoadduct EA1:

    (10) 265.0 parts Epikote 1001 (EEW 475 g/eq) together with 159.7 parts styrene were heated to 60? C., with stirring, in a reaction vessel equipped with a stirrer, reflux cooler, temperature probe, and nitrogen inlet. 29.7 parts diethanolamine were then added dropwise such that the temperature did not exceed 70? C. Stirring was continued until all NH equivalents had reacted and an epoxy amine value of 1.12 mmol/g was achieved.

    (11) Production of the Monomer Mixture:

    (12) 28.9 parts isobornyl methacrylate, 155.1 parts methyl methacrylate, 133.7 parts butyl acrylate, 18.5 parts hydroxyethyl methacrylate, 140.8 parts Araldite GY 2600 (EEW 186 g/eq), 256.5 parts of a crosslinker based on a diphenylmethane diisocyanate oligomer that had been capped with propylene glycol and butyl diglycol, and present in a 90% 1/1 (w/w) mixture composed of butoxypropanol and phenoxypropanol (CathoGuard? 500 crosslinker, commercial product of BASF Coatings GmbH), 3.0 parts tert-dodecyl mercaptan, and 217.7 parts of the emulsifier E1 were added to EA1 and stirred until a solution was present. 27.5 parts of 80% lactic acid were then added, and stirring was continued for 10 minutes at room temperature. 2346.8 parts deionized water were then added, with vigorous stirring. The coarse emulsion which formed was subsequently stirred at least for an additional 5 minutes.

    (13) Production of the Mini-Emulsion:

    (14) The coarse emulsion was transferred to an apparatus for introducing high shear forces, and was subsequently homogenized in two passes at 600 bar with a high-pressure homogenizer (Model 110Y from Microfluidics, equipped with one H230Z and one H210Z homogenization chamber).

    (15) In Situ Polymerization of the Mini-Emulsion for Producing a Primary Dispersion According to the Invention:

    (16) The mini-emulsion was subsequently heated to 75? C., with stirring, in a reaction vessel equipped with a stirrer, reflux cooler, temperature probe, nitrogen inlet, and dosing unit. At a temperature of 75? C., 0.7 parts of a 1% iron(II) sulfate solution were added, and a solution of 3.75 parts sodium formaldehyde sulfoxylate dihydrate in 110.9 parts deionized water was uniformly added dropwise, concurrently with a solution of 5.2 parts of a 70% tert-butyl hydroperoxide solution in 97.1 parts deionized water, over a period of one and one-half hours. Stirring was continued for an additional hour at 75? C. before the mini-emulsion polymerized in situ was cooled to room temperature and filtered (Nylon filter bag with an 80 ?m cutoff).

    (17) Particle size (Z-average): 104 nm

    (18) Particle distribution index (PDI): 0.15

    (19) Solids (after drying for 30 minutes at 180? C.): 32.7% by weight

    (20) In all examples, the particle size distribution was determined by dynamic light scattering, using a Zetasizer Nano S from Malvern. The PDI value was also derived from this measurement.

    (21) Production of a Mini-Emulsion M2 Hybrid Stabilized by an Amino-Functionalized Ethylenically Unsaturated Monomer, and In Situ Polymerization Thereof:

    (22) Production of the Monomer Mixture:

    (23) 25.3 parts isobornyl methacrylate, 135.7 parts methyl methacrylate, 117.0 parts butyl acrylate, 16.2 parts hydroxyethyl methacrylate, 139.7 parts styrene, 353.7 parts Araldite GY 2600 (EEW 186 g/eq), 55.1 parts Super ISO Stable (toluene diisocyanate-trimethylolpropane adduct, blocked with 3 equivalents of phenol, commercial product of Super Urecoat Industries), 2.6 parts tert-dodecyl mercaptan, and 126.0 parts of the emulsifier E1 were stirred in a vessel until a solution was present. A solution consisting of 80.3 parts diethylaminoethyl methacrylate, 19.9 parts formic acid, and 1738.4 parts deionized water was subsequently added slowly, with vigorous stirring. The coarse emulsion which formed was subsequently stirred at least for an additional 5 minutes.

    (24) Production of the Mini-Emulsion:

    (25) The coarse emulsion was transferred to an apparatus for introducing high shear forces, and was subsequently homogenized in two passes at 600 bar with a high-pressure homogenizer (Model 110Y from Microfluidics, equipped with one H230Z and one H210Z homogenization chamber).

    (26) In Situ Polymerization of the Mini-Emulsion for Producing a Primary Dispersion According to the Invention:

    (27) The mini-emulsion was subsequently heated to 75? C., with stirring, in a reaction vessel equipped with a stirrer, reflux cooler, temperature probe, nitrogen inlet, and dosing unit. At a temperature of 75? C., 0.6 parts of a 1% iron(II) sulfate solution were added, and a solution of 3.3 parts sodium formaldehyde sulfoxylate dihydrate in 97.0 parts deionized water was uniformly added dropwise, concurrently with a solution of 4.6 parts of a 70% tert-butyl hydroperoxide solution in 84.9 parts deionized water, over a period of one and one-half hours. Stirring was continued for an additional hour at 75? C. before the mini-emulsion polymerized in situ was cooled to room temperature and filtered (Nylon filter bag with an 80 ?m cutoff).

    (28) Particle size (Z-average): 274 nm

    (29) PDI: 0.24

    (30) Solids (after drying for 30 minutes at 180? C.): 31.1%

    (31) Production of a Mini-Emulsion M3 Stabilized with the Emulsifier E2, and In Situ Polymerization Thereof:

    (32) Production of the Monomer Mixture:

    (33) 22.9 parts isobornyl methacrylate, 123.0 parts methyl methacrylate, 106.0 parts butyl acrylate, 14.7 parts hydroxyethyl methacrylate, 126.7 parts styrene, 320.8 parts Araldite GY 2600 (EEW 186 g/eq), 50.0 parts Super ISO Stable (toluene diisocyanate-trimethylolpropane adduct, blocked with 3 equivalents of phenol, commercial product of Super Urecoat Industries), 2.4 parts tert-dodecyl mercaptan, and 159.5 parts of the emulsifier E2 were stirred in a vessel until a solution was present. 1576.8 parts deionized water were subsequently added slowly, with vigorous stirring. The coarse emulsion which formed was subsequently stirred at least for an additional 5 minutes.

    (34) Production of the Mini-Emulsion:

    (35) The coarse emulsion was transferred to an apparatus for introducing high shear forces, and was subsequently homogenized in two passes at 600 bar with a high-pressure homogenizer (Model 110Y from Microfluidics, equipped with one H230Z and one H210Z homogenization chamber).

    (36) In Situ Polymerization of the Mini-Emulsion:

    (37) The mini-emulsion was subsequently heated to 75? C., with stirring, in a reaction vessel equipped with a stirrer, reflux cooler, temperature probe, nitrogen inlet, and dosing unit. At a temperature of 75? C., 0.6 parts of a 1% iron(II) sulfate solution were added, and a solution of 3.0 parts sodium formaldehyde sulfoxylate dihydrate in 88.0 parts deionized water was uniformly added dropwise, concurrently with a solution of 4.1 parts of a 70% tert-butyl hydroperoxide solution in 77.0 parts deionized water, over a period of one and one-half hours. Stirring was continued for an additional hour at 75? C. before the mini-emulsion polymerized in situ was cooled to room temperature and filtered (Nylon filter bag with an 80 ?m cutoff).

    (38) Particle size (Z-average): 82 nm

    (39) PDI: 0.07

    (40) Solids (after drying for 30 minutes at 180? C.): 31.5%

    (41) Production of a Mini-Emulsion not According to the Invention According to Example 12-1 from WO 82/00148, and In Situ Polymerization Thereof:

    (42) Production of the Monomer Mixture:

    (43) 132.0 parts methyl methacrylate, 88.0 parts butyl acrylate, 27.0 parts hydroxyethyl methacrylate, 160.0 parts of a bisphenol A diglycidyl ether (Epikote 828 (EEW 186 g/eq)), 88.0 parts of a crosslinker based on a diphenylmethane diisocyanate oligomer that had been capped with propylene glycol and butyl diglycol, and present in a 90% 1/1 (w/w) mixture composed of butoxypropanol and phenoxypropanol (CathoGuard? 500 crosslinker, commercial product of BASF Coatings GmbH), 20.0 parts Ethoduomeen T/13 (reaction product of 3 mol ethylene oxide and N-alkyl-1,3-diaminopropane based on a tallow fatty alkyl moiety, commercial product of Firma AkzoNobel N.V.) were stirred in a vessel until a solution was present. A solution consisting of 1200.0 parts deionized water and 64.0 parts Duomac T (N-alkyl-1,3-diaminopropane diacetate based on a tallow fatty alkyl moiety, commercial product of Firma AkzoNobel N.V.) was subsequently added slowly, with vigorous stirring. The coarse emulsion which formed was subsequently stirred at least for an additional 5 minutes.

    (44) Production of the Mini-Emulsion:

    (45) The coarse emulsion was transferred to an apparatus for introducing high shear forces, and was subsequently homogenized in two passes at 600 bar with a high-pressure homogenizer (Model 110Y from Microfluidics, equipped with one H230Z and one H210Z homogenization chamber).

    (46) In Situ Polymerization of the Mini-Emulsion:

    (47) The mini-emulsion was subsequently heated to 75? C., with stirring, in a reaction vessel equipped with a stirrer, reflux cooler, temperature probe, nitrogen inlet, and dosing unit. At a temperature of 75? C., 0.6 parts of a 1% iron(II) sulfate solution were added, and a solution of 3.0 parts sodium formaldehyde sulfoxylate dihydrate in 88.0 parts deionized water was uniformly added dropwise, concurrently with a solution of 4.1 parts of a 70% tert-butyl hydroperoxide solution in 77.0 parts deionized water, over a period of one and one-half hours. Stirring was continued for an additional hour at 75? C. before the mini-emulsion polymerized in situ was cooled to room temperature and filtered (Nylon filter bag with an 80 ?m cutoff).

    (48) Particle size (Z-average): 111 nm

    (49) PDI: 0.12

    (50) Solids (after drying for 30 minutes at 180? C.): 28.8%

    (51) Property Testing of the Mini-Suspensions:

    (52) Production of a Coating Agent Bath from the Mini-Emulsion M1:

    (53) Production of an aqueous preparation for testing the dispersion stability: 1898.7 parts of the mini-emulsion M1 were mixed with 1909.3 parts deionized water. 192.0 parts of an aqueous pigment preparation (CathoGuard? 520 pigment paste, commercial product of BASF Coatings GmbH) were then added, with stirring. The finished bath was stirred for at least 24 additional hours before being tested.

    (54) Pump Test:

    (55) The pumpability of the bath produced above was tested at 32? C. by pumping in a circuit for 24 hours, using a Little Giant MD 4 magnetic drive centrifugal pump. The sieve residue (25 ?m mesh size) was subsequently determined after burning in at 180? C. for 30 minutes. The pumpability was assumed to be adequate with a sieve residue <200 mg/L.

    (56) A sieve residue of 16 mg/L was determined after the test was completed.

    (57) Ultrafiltration Test:

    (58) The ultrafiltration of the bath produced above was carried out via a plate module with PVDF membranes having a total surface area of 880 cm.sup.2 (150 kDa cutoff, commercial product from Microdyn-Nadir GmbH). For assessing the ultrafiltration capability, the flux performance as well as the inlet pressure and outlet pressure were determined over a period of at least one week. The ultrafiltration capability was assumed to be adequate when the flux performance, at a minimum performance of 10 L/hm.sup.2, decreased by less than 20% over the entire test period, with no continuous decrease. The following characteristic data for the above bath were determined during the test:

    (59) TABLE-US-00001 TABLE Ultrafiltration characteristic data Duration Flux performance Change compared Inlet pressure Outlet pressure Temperature [h] [L/hm.sup.2] to start [%] [bar] [bar] [? C.] 0 23.50 0.0 2 0.7 22 17.25 23.90 1.7 1.9 0.7 29 23.25 23.70 0.9 1.9 0.7 28.8 89.45 23.80 1.3 1.9 0.7 26.9 114.7 24.10 2.6 1.9 0.7 28.6 120.2 23.80 1.3 1.9 0.7 29.1 138.7 23.80 1.3 1.9 0.7 27.8 161.2 23.60 0.4 1.9 0.7 27.6

    (60) The flux performance was essentially constant over the test period.

    (61) Production of a Coating Agent Bath from the Mini-Emulsion M2:

    (62) Production of an aqueous preparation for testing the dispersion stability: 1929.3 parts of the mini-emulsion M2 were mixed with 1878.7 parts deionized water. 192.0 parts of an aqueous pigment preparation (CathoGuard? 520 pigment paste, commercial product of BASF Coatings GmbH) were then added, with stirring. The finished bath was stirred for at least 24 additional hours before being tested.

    (63) Pump Test:

    (64) The pump test was carried out as described above.

    (65) A sieve residue of 38 mg/L was determined after the test was completed.

    (66) Ultrafiltration Test:

    (67) The ultrafiltration test was carried out as described above. The following characteristic data were determined during the test:

    (68) TABLE-US-00002 TABLE 2 Ultrafiltration characteristic data Duration Flux performance Change compared Inlet pressure Outlet pressure Temperature [h] [L/hm.sup.2] to start [%] [bar] [bar] [? C.] 0 14.24 0 2 0.1 23.7 2.5 14.89 5 1.8 0.1 25.7 6 15.20 7 1.65 0.1 26.9 22 13.96 ?2 1.6 0.1 25.3 26.5 14.21 0 1.6 0.1 27.1 30.5 14.24 0 1.55 0.1 29.1 48 14.39 1 1.5 0.1 27 52 14.74 4 1.5 0.1 27.1 71 14.80 4 1.45 0.1 27.8 77.5 15.53 9 1.4 0.1 28 96.5 16.02 13 1.45 0.1 28.2 101.5 16.27 14 1.4 0.1 28 170.5 17.67 24 1.4 0.1 29.1

    (69) At the end of the test, the flux performance had increased by 24% compared to the start of the test.

    (70) Production of a Coating Agent Bath from Comparative Example 12-1:

    (71) Production of an aqueous preparation for testing the dispersion stability: 1991.5 parts of the mini-emulsion from Comparative Example 12-1 from WO 82/00148 were mixed with 1816.5 parts deionized water. 192.0 parts of an aqueous pigment preparation (CathoGuard? 520 pigment paste, commercial product of BASF Coatings GmbH) were then added, with stirring. The finished bath was stirred for at least 24 additional hours before being tested.

    (72) Pump Test:

    (73) For this bath, inadequate pumpability was determined solely on a visual basis, since coagulate had settled in the gap between the pump housing and the blade bodies in a large quantity (much more than >1 g/L)

    (74) Ultrafiltration Test:

    (75) On account of the failed pump test, no ultrafiltration test was conducted.